Retail Media Buyers Are Outgrowing ROAS: IAB Europe Report Shows Demand Collapsed From 89% to 49% in One Year

IAB Europe's third Attitudes to Retail Media report finds that ROAS has lost its status as the dominant success metric among European buyers. Incrementality, unified online-offline reporting, and new-to-brand measurement are replacing it — but 61% of buyers say the measurement infrastructure still isn't there.

By Jamie Okonkwo··7 min read

For years, return on ad spend was the number that closed the deal. If a retail media network could show a 5x or 10x ROAS, the budget flowed. That era is ending. IAB Europe's third Attitudes to Retail Media report, released November 3, found that only 49% of European buyers now select ROAS as a desired measurement metric — down from 89% in the 2025 edition of the same survey. It is the sharpest single-year decline in any measurement preference the report has tracked.

The report draws on 150 respondents from advertisers, agencies, retailers, and retail media networks, with this year's edition expanding the sample to include the Middle East and North Africa for the first time. The research was produced by Caras Consulting (quantitative) and Ascentinel (qualitative).

What Replaced ROAS

The decline in ROAS demand did not leave a vacuum. Buyers told IAB Europe they want metrics that answer harder questions: Did the ad cause a sale that would not have happened otherwise? Did it bring in a customer who had never purchased the brand before? Can I see the full picture across online and physical stores?

Specifically, 66% of buyers want unified online and offline reporting, 63% want new-to-brand or new-to-category customer measurement, and 57% want incrementality testing. These are harder metrics to deliver than ROAS — they require control groups, causal inference, and data infrastructure that most retail media networks have not built.

The shift reflects a basic realization that has been building across the industry. As Performance Marketing World framed it, sales attributed to an ad and sales that would not have happened without it are not the same thing. A shopper who searches for a product they buy every week, clicks a sponsored listing, and completes the purchase generates a ROAS event — but the ad may have had zero incremental impact.

The Maturity Problem

The gap between what buyers want and what the market delivers is stark. Only 12% of European buyers consider their retail media strategies fully sophisticated, according to the report. And 61% identify a lack of measurement and reporting as a barrier to further investment — the single largest obstacle cited, ahead of lack of standardization (56%) and fragmentation across retail media networks (56%).

This is not a technology problem in the traditional sense. The methodologies for incrementality testing — geo-based holdouts, matched-market experiments, synthetic control methods — are well established. IAB Europe itself published incrementality guidelines as part of its Commerce Media Measurement Standards V2 in late 2025. The bottleneck is organizational: building the data science capabilities, the clean room infrastructure, and the cross-platform reporting that turns methodology into practice.

On the seller side, the report found that 63% of retail media networks plan to enhance their measurement capabilities in the next 12 months. Whether that investment matches the pace of buyer expectations is the open question.

Parallel Findings Across Markets

The European data does not exist in isolation. IAB Australia's 2026 State of the Nation report, based on a survey of 92 decision-makers, found that 73% of active buyers name inconsistent metrics and definitions across retail media networks as their biggest challenge. In Australia, incremental sales measurement is cited by 83% of active buyers as a desired metric from retail media partners, and ROAS by 76% — still high, but the fact that incrementality now leads suggests the same reordering is happening globally.

Separate research from the Advertising Research Foundation (ARF), reported by The Drum in September, adds a sharper edge. Among the 13 buyers the ARF surveyed, none saw consistent attribution lookback windows across the retail media channels they examined. Five buyers said they had reduced or discontinued investment because of measurement issues. And only five reported full disclosure of statistical methodology from their retail media partners.

The ARF findings are a small sample, but the direction aligns with the IAB Europe data: buyers are not just asking for better measurement — some are pulling budget when they do not get it.

The Broader Context

The decline in ROAS as a default success metric has been building for at least two years. eMarketer reported that the gap between investment and the ability to accurately measure performance continues to widen, even as commerce media spend and measurement capabilities both grow. A Kimberly-Clark executive summarized the dynamic: spending is outpacing the pace of measurement capability.

The problem is structural. Retail media networks are simultaneously the media seller, the measurement provider, and — through their first-party purchase data — the source of truth for outcomes. This creates an inherent conflict that ROAS, as a platform-reported metric, does not resolve. As eMarketer analyst Andrew Lipsman has noted: everyone knows ROAS is imperfect, and everyone is using it anyway — or at least, they were.

IAB Europe's data suggests that period is ending in Europe. The 2025 survey showed 89% of buyers asking for ROAS. The 2026 survey shows 49% for ROAS against 57% for incrementality, so incrementality now leads.

What Measurement Teams Should Watch

The IAB Europe report points to three developments worth tracking:

  • Standards enforcement. The Commerce Media Measurement Standards V2 compliance deadline passed in July 2026. How many retail media networks are actually compliant — and whether buyers are using compliance as a filter — will shape the next phase of the market.
  • Seller investment. With 63% of networks planning measurement upgrades, the question is what form that takes. Independent incrementality testing — where results are validated by a third party who does not operate the media — is what sophisticated buyers increasingly demand.
  • Regional convergence. The parallel findings from IAB Europe and IAB Australia suggest this is a global shift, not a European anomaly. U.S. buyers, who operate in a larger and more mature retail media market, are likely further along the same curve — though the U.S. lacks a comparable pan-market survey to confirm it.
  • The bottom line: ROAS served as the industry's lingua franca because it was easy to calculate and easy to compare. What replaces it will be harder to produce and harder to game — which is exactly the point.